What should Apple do with their cash?

It’s confusing.

Realistically, Apple, or almost any successful tech co., can only do 3 things with their huge piles of cash:

  • Buy other companies; and/or
  • Repurchase their own shares; and/or
  • Declare or increase dividends.

What about using it to hire more engineers? Invest in more R&D? Build more cool products?

That sounds logical, but hiring and spending decrease profits, and “earnings per share.” So that’s the hardest thing actually to use surplus cash for!

Almost counter-intuitively, buying companies doesn’t cost anything. At least, not in the short term, from a financial statement perspective. How can this be? Well, with a bunch of exceptions and limitations, buying another company just swaps one asset on the balance sheet (cash) for another (IP and other tangible and intangible value in the company acquired). If the acquisition fails, years later, they may have to write off its book value. But until then, acquiring another company for cash is almost, sort of, free. It doesn’t come out of your earnings for now, or ever if the deal is a good one.

Also, repurchasing shares also does not hurt earnings. In fact, it does the opposite. It reduces the share count. And that actually increases earnings — per share! It’s sort of like magic. That adds no value to the company, and shrinks its bank account. But again, doesn’t make a hit to earnings.

Dividends also are a sign of a mature company, but increasing them nominally increases shareholder value. Once again, not a hit to profits.

So a ton of cash actually becomes a bit of a trap. You can’t really spend a lot of it without depressing earnings. And if you aren’t super acquisitive (which Apple isn’t), there doesn’t end up being too much to do with it except buy your own stock (often when it is very expensive) or distributing it out.

Apple’s $400 Billion Buyback Program

View original question on quora

Published on July 31, 2019

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This